Chest
Volume 112, Issue 5, November 1997, Pages 1317-1323
Journal home page for Chest

Clinical Investigations in Critical Care
Characteristics and Outcomes of Patients Who Self-Extubate From Ventilatory Support: A Case-Control Study

https://doi.org/10.1378/chest.112.5.1317Get rights and content

Objective

To identify factors associated with the occurrence of deliberate self-extubation and to describe associated patient outcomes.

Design

Case-control study.

Setting

ICUs of a national referral, tertiary medical center.

Participants

Fifty adult, intubated patients who had self-extubated from mechanical ventilatory support. Two control subjects who had not self-extubated were matched to each case based on age, gender, primary discharge diagnosis, and time hospitalized (within same quarter).

Measurements

Standardized coding of medical record information, including demographic characteristics, clinical information, intubation and mechanical ventilation characteristics, medications, and selected laboratory indexes.

Results

As compared to the control subjects, patients who self-extubated were more likely to be medical than surgical patients (p<0.001) and have a current history of smoking (p>0.05). Prior to the self-extubation, patients had a greater likelihood of hospital-acquired infections (p<0.001) or other hospital-acquired adverse events (p>0.001), abnormal (< 10, >50 mg/dL) BUN (p>0.05), and abnormal (>20, >50 mm Hg) PaCO2 (p>0.05); they also were more likely to be restless or agitated (p>0.001), and more likely to be physically restrained (p>0.001). A logistic regression model demonstrated that presence of restlessness or agitation and presence of a hospital-acquired adverse event were independently associated with self-extubation from mechanical ventilatory support. In examining outcomes, as compared to the control subjects, those who self-extubated had longer lengths of stay in ICU and hospital, were more likely to need reintubation, and were more likely to suffer complications from intubation. However, none of the cases died within 48 h of self-extubation.

Conclusion

The results underscore the need for clinical guidelines for weaning and for monitoring patients at risk of self-extubation.

Section snippets

Setting and Sample

The study took place at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, a 1,000-bed national referral center. Cleveland Clinic Foundation has nine adult ICUs (n = 100 beds) with >3,000 patients a year receiving mechanical ventilation.

The cases consisted of all adult patients with occurrences of purposeful SE from mechanical ventilation who were reported by nursing staff to the nursing quality management office during 1993. We defined SE as purposeful patient removal of the ET as witnessed by the nursing

RESULTS

One hundred fifty patients comprised the study sample; 50 who were SE each matched to two patients who were NSE. Results from the univariate analyses are displayed in Table 2, Table 3, Table 4. Table 2 displays the hospital variables for each group. Marginally more of the NSE group returned to home, had a lower rate of discharge to a long-term care setting, and a lower rate of death compared to those in the SE group. Significantly more of the NSE group had a surgical procedure (75%; vs 48%;,

DISCUSSION

SE from mechanical ventilation is a major concern for health-care professionals in the care of ventilated patients. Only a few studies have examined patient factors associated with outcomes of SE.1,5 This retrospective case-control study was conducted to further extend previous work in this area. We found that cases compared to control patients were more often restless or agitated and had more hospital-acquired complications. Furthermore, 25%; of the SE patients did not require reintubation,

Cited by (105)

  • Factors associated with unplanned extubation in the Intensive Care Unit for adult patients: A systematic review and meta-analysis

    2018, Intensive and Critical Care Nursing
    Citation Excerpt :

    For the case control studies, the participants of the no UE group in three of the studies were randomly selected, others were according to case matching. In all the case matching studies, all of them (Chang et al., 2011; Tung et al., 2001; Chang et al., 2008; Atkins et al., 1997) matched cases and controls on basis of gender, age and dates in hospitals, while three of them matched cases and controls on basis of diagnosis (Chang et al., 2011; Tung et al., 2001; Chang et al., 2008), therefore, these studies were taken out of the analysis to assess the impact of these factors on the risk for UE. And for the cohort studies, all the patients were included during the study period.

  • Analgesics, tranquilizers, and sedatives

    2018, Cardiac Intensive Care
  • Management of Sedation and Paralysis

    2016, Clinics in Chest Medicine
  • Relationship between delirium and ventilatory outcomes in the medical intensive care unit

    2020, Critical Care Nurse
    Citation Excerpt :

    Unplanned extubation includes both self-extubation by the patient (intentional or unintentional) and accidental extubation that may occur with patient care activities. Regardless of the cause, unplanned extubation can result in multiple complications, including airway trauma, aspiration pneumonia, respiratory arrest, and reintubation.16 These complications often result in longer hospital stays, increased duration of mechanical ventilation, increased incidence of infections, higher costs, and greater mortality.17,18

View all citing articles on Scopus

Presented in part at the 1996 annual meetings of the American Geriatrics Society/American Federation of Aging Research, Chicago

Reprint requests: Lorraine Mion, PhD, RN, Dept of Nursing Research, P32, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, 9500 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, OH 44195

View full text