Short-term holding room treatment of asthmatic children

doi:10.1016/S0022-3476(85)80340-1

The Journal of Pediatrics

Volume 106, Issue 5, May 1985, Pages 707-711

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0022-3476(85)80340-1 Get rights and content

We undertook a randomized trial to compare holding room treatment vs hospitalization of patients with childhood status asthmaticus. Two thirds of 51 patients were discharged from a holding room within 24 hours (mean 11.8±4.61 hours); the others required hospitalization. One third of 52 hospitalized patients received ≤1 day of intravenously administered therapy, and two thirds received <2 days of therapy (mean 45.6±12 hours). There were no statistically significant differences in recurrence rates between the two groups in the 28 days following status asthmaticus. For patients receiving ≤1 day of therapy, the holding room cost was $526±$226 vs $1439±$339 for hospitalized patients (P<0.001). Thus, holding room therapy for childhood status asthmaticus is both medically and economically effective.

References (12)

LullaS et al.
Emergency management of asthma in children
J Pediatr
(1980)
FantaCH et al.
Glucocorticoids in acute asthma
Am J Med
(1983)
Asthma and other allergic diseases
BannerAS et al.
Rapid prediction of need for hospitalization in acute asthma
JAMA
(1979)
O'BrienSR et al.
Treatment of acute asthmatic attacks in a holding unit of a pediatric emergency room
Ann Allergy
(1980)
ZwickeDL et al.
Use of the emergency department observation unit in the treatment of acute asthma
Ann Emerg Med
(1981)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (56)

Care of Respiratory Conditions in an Observation Unit
2017, Emergency Medicine Clinics of North America
Citation Excerpt :
This extended period of observation affords time for patient teaching and preventative treatments that may lead to decreased recidivism, admissions, morbidity, and mortality.11,12 Numerous studies since the 1980s have demonstrated that treatment of adult and pediatric asthmatics in an EDOU avoids hospitalization, is cost effective, and is clinically beneficial with reduced morbidity and mortality.13–23 Prospective, randomized, clinical trials found greater patient satisfaction and perceived quality of life.17,20,24
Care of Special Populations in an Observation Unit: Pediatrics and Geriatrics
2017, Emergency Medicine Clinics of North America
Citation Excerpt :
In the RCT comparing inpatient versus holding room (HR) treatment of asthma patients, the mean LOS was less for those cared for in the HR compared with on an inpatient service (45.6 hours vs 11.8 hours). Additionally, this care was given in the HR at 44% lower cost than that given as an inpatient.25 In an RCT comparing care provided to infants with dehydration, the mean LOS was ten-fold longer for inpatients than for in the EDOU (9.9 hours vs 103.2 hours).
Effect of using pediatric emergency department virtual observation on inpatient admissions and lengths of stay
2014, Academic Pediatrics
To determine whether using emergency department (ED) virtual observation for select pediatric conditions decreases admission rates for these conditions, and to examine effects on length of stay.
The option of ED virtual observation care for 9 common pediatric conditions was introduced in 2009; associated order sets were developed. Retrospective secondary analyses of administrative data from our tertiary care pediatric ED and children's hospital were performed for the year before (year 0) and after (year 1) this disposition option was introduced. The proportion of visits admitted to the inpatient unit and length of stay (LOS) were determined for all visits considered eligible for ED virtual observation care on the basis of diagnosis codes for both study years.
There were 1614 observation-eligible visits in year 0 and 1510 in year 1. In year 1, 18% (n = 266) of observation-eligible visits received ED virtual observation care. Admission rates for observation-eligible visits were similar after this model of care was introduced (25% year 0, 29% year 1, P = .02). Median LOS for ED virtual observation visits was 8.8 hours (interquartile range 6.5–12.4). ED LOS was shorter for ED discharges (5.6 hours year 0, 5.1 hours year 1, P < .001) and unchanged for admissions (6.0 hours year 0, 5.8 hours, year 1, P = .41) after introducing ED virtual observation.
Admission rates for observation-eligible visits were not lower in the year after ED virtual observation care was introduced. LOS decreased for ED discharges and was unchanged for admissions. Reevaluation of the effects of pediatric ED virtual observation on admission rates and LOS after longer periods of use is indicated.
Short-stay respiratory unit: A new option for inpatient care
2008, Archivos de Bronconeumologia
The current pressure on conventional inpatient care units represents a very serious problem for respiratory medicine departments. The aim of this study was to analyze the impact of a new instrumenta short-stay respiratory uniton the quality of care delivered by the respiratory medicine department of a tertiary care hospital.
The short-stay respiratory unit consisted of 4 conventional hospital beds managed by a pulmonologist. The beds were only used to treat patients diagnosed with exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or bronchial asthma, community-acquired pneumonia, or suspected lung cancer, and stays were intended to only last for less than 4 days. Analyzing a range of healthcare quality variables, we compared the quality of care delivered during the first 6 months the unit was in operation (October 2005 to March 2006) to that delivered in the same period 12 months earlier.
The study included 147 patients admitted to the short-stay unit. The mean (SD) age of the patients was 64 (17) years and 79% were men. The mean length of stay was 3.3 (1.6) days-only 1.4% of patients stayed for longer than 4 days-and the readmission rate was 2.7%. There were no deaths. The existence of the short-stay respiratory unit led to a 30% decrease in the overall mean length of stay in the respiratory medicine department (11.8 [4.6] vs 8.3 [2.6] days; P < .001), and the readmission rate fell from 21% to 15% (P < .05). While there were no differences in mortality between the 2 periods, the complexity of diseases treated by the respiratory medicine department showed an increase of 9.2% (P < .001).
A short-stay respiratory unit can improve the efficiency of care delivered by a respiratory medicine department by reducing both the mean duration of hospitalization and the readmission rate, without a reduction in the complexity of diseases treated or a need for additional resources.
La presión asistencial sobre la hospitalización convencional es un problema acuciante en los servicios de neumología. El propósito del estudio ha sido analizar el impacto de un nuevo dispositivo, la unidad neumológica de estancia corta (UNEC), sobre la calidad de la atención en el servicio de neumología de un hospital terciario.
La UNEC se dotó de 4 camas de hospitalización convencional, gestionadas por un neumólogo especializado. En ella ingresaron sólo pacientes con diagnósticos de exacerbación de enfermedad pulmonar obstructiva crónica (EPOC) o asma bronquial, neumonía extrahospitalaria o sospecha de cáncer de pulmón, y previsión de estancia inferior a 4 días. Se analizó el período de puesta en funcionamiento de la unidad (6 meses, de octubre a marzo) frente al mismo período del año anterior, valorándose los distintos índices de calidad asistencial.
Se incluyó a 147 pacientes (79% varones), con una media ± desviación estándar de edad de 64 ± 17 años. La estancia media en la UNEC fue de 3,3 ± 1,6 días -sólo un 1,4% de los pacientes superó los 4 días- y la tasa de reingresos, del 2,7%. No hubo mortalidad. Con la UNEC, la estancia media global en el servicio disminuyó un 30% (de 11,8 ± 4,6 a 8,3 ± 2,6 días; p < 0,001), al igual que los reingresos (del 21 al 15%; p < 0,05), sin cambios en la mortalidad. Sin embargo, la complejidad de las enfermedades ingresadas en neumología aumentó un 9,2% (p < 0,001).
La UNEC puede mejorar la eficiencia de la atención neumológica al disminuir la estancia media hospitalaria y la tasa de reingresos, sin reducir la complejidad de las enfermedades atendidas ni precisar recursos adicionales específicos.
An evaluation of emergency physician selection of observation unit patients
2006, American Journal of Emergency Medicine
Appropriate patient selection is critical for maximal observation unit (OU) effectiveness. We hypothesized emergency physicians underuse the OU for admitted patients and overuse the OU for patients who would otherwise be discharged.
Treating emergency physicians were asked about patient suitability for admission to an OU at a busy, urban, academic emergency department (ED) as part of a prospective cohort study of ED patients who were admitted or had an ED length of stay exceeding 4 hours. The OU was closed for renovation during the 2-month study, so physician opinion could be compared with patient course in the absence of observation services. Two blinded emergency physicians reviewed charts using structured forms and explicit definitions to determine actual patient course. Hospitalized patients were considered potential OU candidates according to a priori criteria: (1) hospital length of stay less than 48 hours, (2) no procedure or diagnosis requiring hospitalization, and (3) no death.
Of 1747 enrolled patients, 131 were excluded with incomplete data. Median age was 45 years. Patients were 40% white and 48% men. Emergency physicians identified 363 (23%) patients as observation candidates. Of these, 182 (50%) were actually discharged directly. The remaining 181 (50%) were hospitalized; 101 (56%) were observation candidates based on chart review. Of 799 admitted patients not selected for observation, 232 (29%) were suitable for observation by chart review.
Selection of patients for observation was suboptimal; emergency physicians routinely identified patients as OU candidates who were not ultimately admitted, and they missed many admitted patients who might have been appropriate OU candidates. Both over- and underuse should be addressed to maximize the effectiveness of OUs.
Inter-rater evaluation of a clinical scoring system in children with asthma
2002, Annals of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology
Many clinical scores that measure the degree of asthma are used without adequate evaluation of inter-rater reliability. When reliability is tested, most often the Cohen κ statistic is used, which limits the comparative results of only two raters at a time.
To evaluate inter-rater agreement of a clinical asthma score using a multi-rater κ statistic.
Four raters administered a clinical asthma score to 17 children with clinical asthma. Five items were evaluated: O₂ requirement, inspiratory breath sounds, accessory muscle use, expiratory wheeze, and cerebral function. For each, a score of zero indicated a normal state; one, moderate impairment; two, severe impairment. A multi-rater κ statistic was used as a measure of agreement among all four raters simultaneously. This was applied using hand calculations then cross-checked by using a standard statistical syntax, a component of the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS 9.0).
Application of the multi-rater κ statistic revealed strong agreement among raters on oxygenation (K = 0.759), moderate agreement for expiratory wheeze and cerebral function (K = 0.698), and poor agreement for accessory muscle use (K = 0.528) and inspiratory breath sounds (K = 0.316).
The level of agreement varied by item with the least subjective item, O₂ requirement, demonstrating the highest inter-rater correlation. A multi-rater κ statistic can be applied to data obtained from a clinical scoring instrument either manually or by using statistical syntax provided by SPSS.

View all citing articles on Scopus

¹: Supported by the Bowman C. Lingle Trust Allergy Research Fund (J.J.H.)

View full text

Original articleShort-term holding room treatment of asthmatic children

J Pediatr

Am J Med

Asthma and other allergic diseases

Rapid prediction of need for hospitalization in acute asthma

JAMA

Treatment of acute asthmatic attacks in a holding unit of a pediatric emergency room

Ann Allergy

Use of the emergency department observation unit in the treatment of acute asthma

Ann Emerg Med

Original article
Short-term holding room treatment of asthmatic children