Table 3

Quality assessment of included studies using QI-MCS (met=1, not met=0)

Organi-
sational motivation
Inter-
vention rationale
Inter-
vention description
Organi-
sational characteristics
Imple- mentationStudy designCom-
parator
Data sourceTimingAdherence/
fidelity
Health outcomesOrgani-
sational readiness
Penetration/
reach
Sustain-
ability
SpreadLimitationsTotal (max possible=16)
McLeod (2003)2610101011100101109
Kuper (2011)27111111110111001113
McNaney (2011)2310000011011101108
Potgieter (2012)19111010010111011010
Huddart (2015)20111010111111011113
Standards for QUality Improvement Reporting Excellence 2.0 guidelines41 published (2016)
Feinberg (2018)24011111011111001112
Aggarwal (2019)21111010111110001111
Peden (2019)22111011011111001112
Tadd (2019)28111010011111011011
Bamber (2019)25111011011001111112
  • QI-MCS, Quality Improvement Minimum Criteria Set.